Wood-fired Neapolitan, crispy New York-style & local favorites • 3.5+ star rated
From nationally recognized Neapolitan pies to classic New York-style and wood-fired classics, Pensacola delivers excellent pizza. Here are the top-rated spots (3.5+ stars) for the best pizza in Pensacola.
Downtown Pensacola's fresh-baked pizza cones and sweet dessert cones on S. Palafox — a fun twist on the classic. It's a pizza, in a cone!
Nationally ranked in 50 Top Pizza USA 2026. Outstanding sourdough Neapolitan-style pies in downtown Pensacola.
Authentic Italian wood-fired pizzas baked in a 500° imported oven. Consistently one of the highest-rated in town.
Premier New York-style pizza on the Gulf Coast. Crispy, foldable slices and local favorite for over a decade.
Art-inspired New York-style pies with fresh ingredients and vibrant downtown atmosphere.
Classic New York-style pizza paired with excellent deli sandwiches. High ratings and generous portions.
Local hidden gem in East Hill known for outstanding pizzas and friendly service.
East Hill institution with fluffy-crispy crust, great toppings, and pub atmosphere.
Authentic Italian pizzas and pastas with fresh ingredients and strong local following.
Pro Tip: Many offer online ordering, happy hour specials, and DoorDash/Uber Eats for quick delivery.